Views and Experiences with End-of-Life Medical Care in Japan, Italy, the United States, and Brazil: A Cross-Country Survey
Country Highlights: Brazil
Among the countries surveyed, Brazilians stand out as having the most negative views of their health care system, yet they are the most likely to defer to doctors when it comes to end-of-life decision making.
In Brazil, a country whose state-sponsored health care system has been plagued by problems, nine in ten residents give the health care system a rating of “fair” or “poor” both in general (90 percent) and when it comes to providing end-of-life medical care (86 percent), by far the most negative ratings among the countries surveyed.
Brazilians are also the most likely of any country surveyed to say that most people in their country have too little control over their own medical care at the end of life (79 percent). Despite this sense that people should have more control, Brazilians are more likely than residents of the other countries surveyed to say that doctors should have the greater say in which medical treatments to pursue for seriously ill patients; 4 in 10 say doctors should have the greater say, while about half say patients and their families should have the greater say. And among Brazilians who have not discussed their own end-of-life wishes with a loved one, the main reason given is that they will trust their doctor to make those decisions for them when the time comes.
Brazilians stand out as being more likely than residents of other countries surveyed to focus on religion and spirituality when it comes to end-of-life issues.
Eight in ten Brazilians (83 percent) say their religious or spiritual beliefs play a major role in how they think about their own wishes for end-of-life medical treatment, compared to about half of residents in the U.S. and Italy and just 13 percent in Japan. Forty-four percent of adults in Brazil identify as Catholic and three in ten identify as Evangelical; these groups are about equally likely to say their beliefs play a major role in their thinking on these issues.
When asked the importance of various factors in thinking about their own death, “being at peace spiritually” ranks number one in Brazil, with 40 percent saying it is extremely important and another 49 percent saying it is very important. In contrast to the other countries surveyed, a quarter of Brazilians (26 percent) say that living as long as possible is extremely important to them, placing it on par with other concerns like having loved ones around, making sure your family is not burdened financially, and making sure your wishes about medical care are followed.
Some attitudes about end-of-life care in Brazil differ by gender and education level.
Among Brazilians, women are more likely than men to say they have thought a great deal about how they would pay for the costs of medical care and other services they or another family member might need in old age (50 percent vs. 36 percent) and who would provide care for them or another family member if someone became seriously ill and needed special support (51 percent vs. 40 percent). However, men are more likely than women to report discussing their own wishes for end-of-life treatment with a health care provider (14 percent versus 6 percent).
While Brazil is a relatively young country, Brazilians with higher levels of education appear to be more concerned than their less-educated counterparts about the issue of population aging. Nearly six in ten university graduates (56 percent) say the growing number of older adults in Brazil is a major problem, compared with about a third (34 percent) of those with a primary education or less.
There is also a difference based on education level in Brazilians’ attitudes about extending life. While Brazilians overall are more likely to prioritize prolonging life over helping people die without pain, discomfort, and stress, university grads lean in the other direction (58 percent say reducing pain and stress should be more important).Country Highlights: Italy Methodology