Potential Impact of Additional Federal Funds for Medicaid HCBS for Seniors and People with Disabilities
Home and community-based services (HCBS) help seniors and people with disabilities and chronic illnesses live independently outside institutions by assisting with daily needs. HCBS include but are not limited to home health aide services, assistance with self-care tasks such as eating or bathing, supportive housing, and assistive technology. People who use HCBS include seniors with physical and/or cognitive limitations, people with intellectual disabilities such as Down’s syndrome or autism, people with physical disabilities such as spinal cord injuries or cerebral palsy, people with serious mental illness, and people with disabling chronic conditions.
The unmet need for HCBS for seniors and people with disabilities pre-dates the COVID-19 pandemic, with Medicaid serving as the primary source of coverage for HCBS. These services are unaffordable out-of-pocket for many people and unavailable through private insurance or Medicare. The pandemic’s disproportionate impact on seniors and people with disabilities, particularly those living in congregate settings such as nursing homes, has brought heightened focus on the need for additional HCBS, and the growing elderly population in the coming years will further intensify the need for these services. Over the last several decades, states have focused on shifting the Medicaid program’s historical bias toward institutional services by devoting an increasing share of their total long-term services and supports (LTSS) spending to HCBS. Spending on HCBS surpassed spending on institutional care for the first time in FY 2013 and comprised 56% of total Medicaid LTSS spending in FY 2018, with substantial variation among states.
The American Rescue Plan, the COVID relief package recently signed into law by President Biden, includes a provision to increase the federal matching rate (FMAP) for spending on Medicaid HCBS by 10 percentage points from April 1, 2021 through March 31, 2022 provided states maintain state spending levels as of April 1, 2021. This brief discusses the provision and provides state by state estimates of the potential effects of the policy change.
What does the new law do for HCBS?
The HCBS provision in the American Rescue Plan will increase the federal matching rate (FMAP) for Medicaid HCBS spending by 10 percentage points from April 1, 2021 through March 31, 2022. The bill specifies that states must use the enhanced funds to “implement, or supplement the implementation of, one or more activities to enhance, expand, or strengthen” Medicaid HCBS. While the current version of the bill does not detail specific activities, examples of initiatives that states might fund include bolstering the workforce by supporting direct care workers, family caregivers, and/or HCBS providers adversely affected by the pandemic; offering services to address the pandemic’s impact on seniors and people with disabilities; and/or increasing the number of people receiving HCBS (Figure 1).
The bill would increase the total dollars available for Medicaid HCBS, as states would be required to maintain their current HCBS spending to qualify for the enhanced federal funds. Specifically, states would have to maintain their level of HCBS spending as of April 1, 2021. The proposed 10 percentage point increase for HCBS would be added to the state’s regular Medicaid matching rate (which ranges from 50% to 78% in FY 2022), as well as to other FMAP increases available to states, including the 6 percentage point increase for Community First Choice attendant care services, the 6.2 percentage point increase provided to address the COVID-19 public health emergency (PHE) under the Families First Coronavirus Response Act, any disaster recovery FMAP (available to states with a federally declared disaster and a certain amount of FMAP decline), and the 90% federal matching rate for Medicaid expansion adults under the ACA, as well as a proposed 5 percentage point increase in the regular matching rate for states newly adopting the ACA expansion provided in a separate section of the bill. The cumulative enhanced matching rate for Medicaid HCBS under the bill would be capped at 95%.
What is the estimated effect of the provision for states?
We estimate that nationally, federal spending for HCBS could increase by about $11.4 billion (Table 1). This estimate is similar to that put out by the Congressional Budget Office, which estimated increased federal costs of approximately $12.7 billion. In the time period that the FMAP increase would be in effect (the final two quarters of FY 2021 and the first two quarters of FY 2022), we estimate that total federal and state Medicaid HCBS spending will be approximately $114 billion (Table 1). Estimated total Medicaid HCBS spending varies widely by state, ranging from $198 million dollars in Wyoming to nearly $22 billion in California. The additional $11.4 billion federal dollars from this FMAP increase would be distributed proportional to the size of state HCBS programs, with California receiving nearly $2.2 billion additional federal dollars and Wyoming receiving about $19.8 million additional federal dollars. This wide state variation reflects both state size and various state policy choices on HCBS programs, nearly all of which are offered at state option.
These estimates are made with a degree of uncertainly. Our estimates reflect HCBS spending in FY 2021 and FY 2022 based on inflation rates from CBO’s projected spending on Medicaid LTSS. However, these estimates do not account for states expanding underlying HCBS spending beyond current levels due to the additional federal incentive. Additionally, some spending in some states may not be eligible for the full increase, should the state hit the 95% federal match cap, after accounting for the 10 percentage point increase in the bill as well as other enhanced matching rates available to states, such as the enhanced match for the ACA Medicaid expansion group. These estimates assume that all states maintain their current spending levels, as required by the bill.
|This data note uses spending data from KFF’s FY 2018 HCBS program surveys and FY 2018 Medicaid expenditure data from CMS Financial Management Reports to estimate the amount of additional federal funds available to each state under the proposed FMAP increase. The estimates rely primarily on state-reported data from KFF’s FY 2018 HCBS program survey for expenditures on home health, personal care, Community First Choice, and Section 1915 (i) state plan services as well as HCBS expenditures provided through Section 1915 (c) and Section 1115 waivers. These categories make up the vast majority of Medicaid HCBS spending, and our estimates include capitated spending in these categories.
There are also several additional HCBS categories identified in the bill that are eligible for the HCBS match but are not covered by our annual HCBS survey. These categories are PACE, Section 1915 (b) primary care case management, Section 1915 (j) personal care assistance, state plan case management services, and state plan rehabilitative services. FY 2018 spending for these additional categories are pulled from FY 2018 CMS-64 reports and reflect only fee-for-service spending. These totals reflect about $7.5 billion out of a total of $100 billion in estimated Medicaid HCBS spending in FY 2018. HCBS spending was then summed across all program authorities to identify Medicaid HCBS state totals for FY 2018.
These totals were inflated using CBO’s projected Medicaid LTC spending baseline from FY 2019 to FY 2022. Since CBO’s current published estimates do not include baseline Medicaid LTC spending for FY 2018, the same amount of growth was used to estimate spending from FY 2018 to FY 2019 as FY 2019 to FY 2020. Annual growth rates using CBO’s Medicaid LTC baseline range from 3.0% to 4.2% from FY 2019 – FY 2022. Total Medicaid HCBS spending for the four quarters during which this additional federal match would be available reflects half of estimated Medicaid HCBS spending from FY 2021 and half of the estimated Medicaid HCBS spending from FY 2022, which amounts to approximately $114 billion (Table 1). Additional federal dollars available through the proposed FMAP bump are calculated by taking 10% of estimated state and national totals from this time period. We assume that this bill is intended to provide fiscal relief with a stipulation that states use new funds from the FMAP increase to “supplement and not supplant” current state spending.