What’s in a Name? From Today’s Medicare to Medicare for All

Author: Larry Levitt
Published: Oct 29, 2026

Editorial Note: This article was originally published by JAMA Health Forum on Oct. 29, 2026

For many years, the idea of a national health care program covering everyone in the country was known as a single-payer system because the government would be the primary payer for health care, as in Canada’s national health system. In the early 2000s, advocates shifted to describing a universal health care plan as Medicare for All, drawing on the longstanding popularity of the Medicare program.

The rebranding has political merit. A KFF poll conducted in 2019 found that 63% of people had a positive reaction to the term “Medicare-for-all” compared with 49% who reacted positively to “single-payer health insurance system,” and 46% with a positive view of “socialized medicine.” An October 2026 KFF poll found the highest level of support for Medicare for All since KFF began polling on the topic in 2026, but support falls sharply when respondents are presented with common arguments critics make.

There have been a variety of Medicare for All proposals from political leaders and health advocacy groups. The 2 leading Medicare for All proposals in Congress—similar bills introduced by Senator Bernie Sanders (S.1506) and Representative Pramila Jayapal (H.R.3069)—would establish a universal health care program covering all US residents. These bills, which are the most detailed Medicare for All proposals that have been issued, would differ significantly from the current Medicare program, calling attention to some of the gaps and trade-offs that exist in the program today.

Premiums

Under the current proposed legislation, all US residents would be covered by Medicare for All with no required premium. By contrast, premiums in the current Medicare program can be substantial.

The standard premium to enroll in Medicare Part B—which covers services such as physician visits, imaging, laboratory tests, and durable medical equipment—is now $202.90 per month, but beneficiaries considered to be high-income pay supplemental premiums. Generally, all Medicare beneficiaries are required to pay the Part B premium unless they qualify for financial assistance available for people with low incomes.

Signing up for a private Medicare Part D standalone drug plan typically requires an additional premium, averaging $36 per month for beneficiaries in traditional Medicare, also with higher premiums for higher-income beneficiaries. Additionally, about 4 in 10 people in traditional Medicare buy a private Medigap insurance policy to fully or partially cover patient cost-sharing charges in Medicare. Medigap premiums averaged $217 per month in 2023.

Patient Cost Sharing

Both Sanders’ and Jayapal’s Medicare for All bills would cover health care with no patient cost-sharing—that is, no deductibles, copays, or coinsurance. That’s not typically the case under universal health care programs in other countries and is quite different from Medicare today. Taxes would have to increase to pay for these versions of Medicare for All, replacing premiums and cost sharing. How much people would pay would depend on which taxes are used to finance the system, but their costs would no longer vary by how much health care they use.

Currently, Medicare Part A has a deductible of $1736 per hospital admission (which also covers any readmission within 60 days). Patients with multiple admissions in a year could pay multiple deductibles. There are also daily copays for lengthy hospital or skilled nursing facility stays. Part B has a separate annual deductible of $283, with 20% coinsurance after the deductible is met. Many preventive services are covered with no cost sharing. There is no out-of-pocket cap in Parts A or B, meaning patients with expensive illnesses can and do incur substantial bills.

Cost sharing in Part D drug plans varies by plan, with an average annual drug deductible of $544 for beneficiaries in traditional Medicare, plus copays and coinsurance that differ by drug. Out-of-pocket costs for drugs are capped at $2100 per year.

Benefits

The Medicare for All proposals in Congress would cover the comprehensive health services included in Medicare today, plus some notable services traditional Medicare currently excludes, such as dental, vision, audiology, abortion, and home and community-based long-term care.

Role of Private Insurance Plans

Both Medicare for All bills would effectively eliminate the role of private health insurance. The federal government would pay for health care directly, and insurance companies would be prohibited from selling coverage that duplicated the universal program. Insurers could, in theory, sell supplemental coverage for uncovered services, but the benefits specified by the legislation are so comprehensive that there likely would be no market for such coverage. Conversely, private insurers have played a growing role in the current Medicare program. More than half of beneficiaries now choose to enroll in a private Medicare Advantage plan.

Medicare Advantage plans typically have limited networks of physicians and hospitals and frequently require prior authorization for certain services (which has been rare in traditional Medicare, though there are efforts to expand its use). In return, Medicare Advantage plans often offer supplemental benefits, lower cost sharing for some services, and are required to have an out-of-pocket cap. Most Medicare Advantage enrollees are in plans that charge no premium, other than the Part B premium, including for drug coverage. Although premiums for drug coverage are uncommon in Medicare Advantage, enrollees still face cost-sharing for drugs, including an average deductible of $371 and varying cost-sharing amounts for covered drugs.

Reimbursement Rates

Under the Sanders and Jayapal Medicare for All proposals, the health care system would operate under a national health budget, established each year by the Secretary of Health and Human Services. There is no set budget for Medicare today. Reimbursement rates paid to health care professionals under these Medicare for All bills would be set by the government, as they typically are today in Medicare, but with some noteworthy differences. Rather than being paid based on diagnosis-related groups (DRGs), each hospital would receive a lump sum global budget to cover all operating expenses.

The federal government would negotiate prices for all drugs with pharmaceutical companies. Medicare has traditionally been prohibited from negotiating drug prices but now does so for a defined number of high-cost drugs under the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act.

What Would a Medicare for All System Ultimately Look Like?

Medicare for All proposals will raise many complex questions if they become the subject of serious political debate. How much would total health spending change and what would be the impact on hospital and physician revenues? Who would pay more and who would pay less? What would be the effects on access to care, quality of care, overall health, and mortality? How would the public react to switching from their current insurance arrangements to a Medicare for All system?

A drawn-out legislative debate over Medicare for All would mean furious lobbying by the health care industry and likely compromises along the way. Premiums and cost sharing or more limited benefits might be considered, shifting costs to patients while also lowering the cost to the government and reducing the tax increase required to finance the system. Physicians and hospitals would argue for guarantees of higher payment rates, pushing costs up. Insurance companies would advocate for a continued role as with Medicare Advantage plans, which would preserve some continuity with the current system but also add complexity and administrative overhead.

Given these and other competing interests, a Medicare for All system could end up looking more like today’s Medicare program than the proposals introduced in Congress. Medicare is a popular and proven program, which is why Medicare for All proposals use Medicare’s trusted name and infrastructure. But when compared with Medicare for All plans, Medicare’s coverage today is, in fact, not as comprehensive and affordable for those already eligible as many might believe. Medicare for All is unlikely to be enacted in the near future, but the political push for it could prompt a debate about the services Medicare itself does not cover and the high costs current Medicare beneficiaries can incur.