Impact of Potential Changes to ERISA: Litigation and Appeals Experience of CalPERS, Other Large Public Employers and a Large California Health Plan

Published: May 30, 1998

The Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) currently preempts state law related to the wrongful denial or delay of health benefits to the extent that such laws relate to a health benefit plan sponsored by a private employer. This report examines the frequency, nature and costs associated with the appeals and litigation that state and local governmental employers have experienced. Information was gathered through multiple telephone interviews with individuals with extensive involvement in administrative appeals and litigation experience of health benefit issues for these government-sponsored health benefit programs.

1998 National Survey of Latinos on HIV/AIDS – Report (HTML version)

Published: May 1, 1998

1998 National Survey of Latinos on HIV/AIDSThis Report is also available in PDF

  • in English (.pdf)
  • en Espanol (.pdf)

CONTENTS

 

INTRODUCTION

The number of reported AIDS cases in the United States has reached 600,000 including 65,000 new cases reported since July of 1996.1 There are an estimated 650,000 to 900,000 2 individuals living with HIV, including AIDS, in the US. Despite treatment advances, transmission continues at alarming rates, particularly for certain subpopulations. Latinos 3 and other ethnic and racial minorities have been particularly hard hit.

Latinos have been disproportionately impacted by HIV since the beginning of the epidemic. Although Latinos accounted for only 7 percent of the US population, they represented 13 percent of all AIDS cases in 1982. 4 Today, 20 percent of new AIDS cases are among Latinos even though Latinos account for just 11 percent of the total population. 5 Approximately 110,000 to 170,000 Latinos are currently infected with HIV 6 of whom an estimated 45,400 are living with AIDS. 7

THE LATINO POPULATION IN THE UNITED STATESLatinos constitute one of the fastest growing ethnic minorities in the US, with a resident population of nearly 30 million. The Latino population is expected to reach 96 million, 25 percent of the predicted US population, halfway into the next century. 8 The Latino population living in the US is diverse, representing multiple ethnicities and countries of origin. Latinos are primarily from the following countries of origin: Mexico, Puerto Rico, Cuba, and the Dominican Republic. The Latino population is concentrated in the northeastern, western and southwestern regions of the US. These areas also include many of the nation’s AIDS epicenters. Among Latinos, AIDS case rates per 100,000 are highest in the Northeastern states 9 (see special section on the relationship between Regional Location and attitudes toward/ knowledge of HIV/AIDS among Latinos).

1392-fig1

 

Overall, the nation’s Latino population is younger, disproportionately poor, and has lower educational attainment than the US population as a whole. The population includes different waves of immigration and, for many, a language barrier still exists (see special section on the relationship between Language and attitudes about/knowledge of HIV/AIDS among Latinos).

Values and traditions unique to Latino culture play an important role in shaping attitudes and behaviors with respect to sex, sexuality, drug use and HIV/AIDS. These attitudes and behaviors may affect risk for HIV/AIDS as well as diagnosis and treatment. 10

EPIDEMIOLOGY AND TRANSMISSION OF HIV/AIDSIn the United States, Latinos make up 18 percent of the total AIDS cases reported since the start of the epidemic through June of 1997. Latinos represent 17 percent of all cases among men and 20 percent of the total number of cases reported among women. 11For Latino men, the current AIDS case rate (the number of cases relative to population size) is nearly three times that for white non-Hispanic men (94.5 cases per 100,000 compared to 32.5 cases per 100,000). For women, the rate is six times higher (23 cases per 100,000 compared to 3.8 cases per 100,000). 12

In general, sex with men is the most common reported mode of transmission among Latino men (37 percent of new cases, 44 percent of all cases reported) followed by injection drug use (32 percent of new cases, 37 percent of all cases reported). Injection drug use also figures significantly in HIV transmission among Latino women (Latinas), though infection due to injection drug use has declined in recent years. Injection drug use is the primary risk factor for 33 percent of new cases and 43 percent of all cases reported among Latinas. Heterosexual contact is the leading HIV transmission route for Latinas and accounts for 47 percent of new AIDS cases (compared to 40 percent of new cases among all women and 46 percent of all reported cases). 13

THE HEALTH GAP AND ACCESS TO CARERecent treatment advances, particularly the increasing availability of effective drug therapies to prevent AIDS-related opportunistic infections (OIs) and the introduction of new drugs which combat HIV (e.g., protease inhibitors) have positively impacted individuals living with HIV. Treatment advances have led to some optimism about the future of the epidemic. For example, AIDS-related mortality is dropping and many people are living longer with HIV. However, this drop has not been occurring at the same rate for all populations. Whereas the number of AIDS deaths in 1996 declined by 32 percent from the previous year among non-Hispanic whites, the decline was only 20 percent among Latinos. 14

Latinos continue to die from AIDS at a rate two and a half times that of non-Hispanic whites. Today HIV is the fourth leading cause of death for Latinos and the eighth leading cause in the general population. 15

These disparities in health outcomes may reflect differential access to health care services. Lack of insurance limits access to health care for a significant proportion of the Latino population. Approximately one in three Latinos (34 percent) are uninsured, and 30 percent report having no regular source of health care. And families with Latino heads of household are more likely than families headed by white or African American individuals to report barriers to receiving health care, most often citing inability to pay for care as the major obstacle. 16 Such obstacles may stand in the way of HIV prevention education as well as early diagnosis and ongoing treatment of HIV. The impact of HIV/AIDS on Latinos should thus be considered in the context of broader disparities in access to health care services.

LATINOS’ PERCEPTIONS OF THE HIV/AIDS EPIDEMICGiven the disproportionate impact of the HIV/AIDS epidemic on Latinos, it is important to understand the opinions and perceptions of Latinos with respect to HIV/AIDS. How do Latinos view the HIV/AIDS epidemic? What are Latinos’ perceptions of America’s response to the HIV/AIDS crisis? Do Latinos differ in their knowledge and information needs with respect to the disease?

From the outset of the AIDS epidemic, public opinion and knowledge have significantly shaped the US response to the epidemic and have informed national dialogues about prevention, treatment and research. Public attitudes and perceptions have influenced not only local and national responses (including public health measures, federal spending priorities, and community mobilization) but also the experiences of individuals confronting HIV/AIDS in their own lives. And these efforts and experiences, in turn, have shaped what people living in the US think and understand about HIV/AIDS.

Past surveys have aimed to capture general public sentiment about HIV/AIDS, including perceptions of the epidemic; personal worry about becoming infected with HIV; knowledge of transmission, course and treatment of HIV and AIDS; experiences with testing; views of national and local efforts to halt the epidemic; and sources of information about HIV/AIDS. Less understood are public opinion and knowledge among minority groups, whose views are often overshadowed in surveys of the population at large. Racial and ethnic minorities are typically sampled in proportion to their contribution to the total population. While these surveys give an important voice to minority groups, they often lack samples of sufficient size to permit detailed analysis. The importance of doing more to understand the perceptions and knowledge of US Latinos is underscored not only by the impact of HIV/AIDS on the Latino community but also by the diversity of the Latino population. For these reasons, the Kaiser Family Foundation surveyed a large sample of Latino adults to characterize their views, concerns, and knowledge about HIV/AIDS today.

In this report, we first present findings from the overall sample of Latino respondents, and then take a closer look at several Latino subgroups.

The Kaiser Family Foundation Survey of Latinos on HIV/AIDS is intended to inform and stimulate increased dialogue about HIV/AIDS in Latino communities as well as provide a better understanding of Latino perspectives on HIV/AIDS to all those who are working to reduce the social, economic and individual costs of the AIDS epidemic.

METHODOLOGYThe Kaiser Family Foundation National Survey of Latinos on HIV/AIDS was designed by the Kaiser Family Foundation and conducted for the Foundation by Princeton Survey Research Associates. The data were collected from a national sample of Latinos in conjunction with a larger study of the general public knowledge and opinion about HIV/AIDS. The sample included respondents living in the continental US only (Puerto Rico, Alaska, and Hawaii were not included). Participants in the Latino survey were interviewed by telephone in either English or Spanish between September 19 and October 26, 1997. Respondents were selected if they selfidentified as Hispanic or Latino. The responses from a total of 802 interviews of Latino adults, age 18 or older, are reported here. Data were weighted to match US Census Bureau estimates of age, sex, education and regional distribution of Latino adults living in households with telephones in the continental United States. The margin of sampling error for results based on the total sample is plus or minus 4 percentage points although the margin of error is larger for some subgroups.

FINDINGS: AIDS VIEWED WITH URGENCY AND GROWING PERSONAL CONCERNLatinos clearly see the impact of AIDS on the nation and in local communities. Nine in ten Latinos (91 percent) say AIDS is a major threat to public health in this country.

One in two Latinos (50 percent) rate AIDS as the most urgent health problem facing the nation today. Half as many (24 percent) say cancer is the most urgent problem. By comparison, 38 percent of the general public 17 says AIDS is the most urgent health problem today, tying it with cancer (also 38 percent).

Latinos view AIDS not only as a serious problem but also one that is becoming more pressing. Two in three Latinos (67 percent) say AIDS is a more urgent problem for the country today than it was even a few years ago. While many Latinos believe the country is making progress in fighting the AIDS epidemic (44 percent), one in three (32 percent) say the country is losing ground.

1392-fig2

 

1392-fig3

 

In addition to viewing AIDS as an escalating problem for the nation, Latinos view AIDS with increasing concern for local communities. One in two (52 percent) say AIDS is a more urgent problem in their local communities than just a few years ago and one in five (20 percent) say their community is losing ground in the fight against AIDS. By comparison, 25 percent of the general public sees AIDS as a more urgent problem for local communities and 11 percent says their community is losing ground. The public overall is twice as likely as Latinos to say AIDS has never been a problem for their local community (41 percent for the general public compared to 21 percent of Latinos).

PERSONAL EXPERIENCE WITH AND WORRY ABOUT HIV/AIDSFor Latinos, AIDS is not something that only happens to others; for many, AIDS hits close to home. Two thirds (67 percent) of Latinos say AIDS is a very serious problem for people they know compared to 34 percent of the general public. And one in three Latinos (35 percent) say they personally know someone who has HIV or AIDS or who died from AIDS.

Latinos’ sense of urgency about AIDS is reflected in heightened personal worry about becoming infected with HIV. Nearly half (46 percent) of Latinos are very concerned about getting HIV and two in five (41 percent) say their concern about infection has grown in recent years. Latino worry is nearly twice as high as that of the general public (24 percent of the general public is very concerned about becoming infected with HIV).

Personal worry also extends to worry about children. Seven in ten Latino parents (70 percent) are very concerned about their kids getting HIV (compared to 52 percent of all parents). For 58 percent of Latinos, concern about kids is greater today than a few years ago.

Latinos are slightly more likely than the general public to have been tested for HIV (42 percent of Latinos compared to 38 percent of the general public), with most having tested in the past year (23 percent compared to 16 percent of the general public).

LATINOS RATE COMMUNITY GROUPS HIGHER THAN GOVERNMENT IN THE FIGHT AGAINST AIDSMore than half of Latinos (59 percent) say local health care providers care “a lot” about the fight against AIDS and one in two say local churches (50 percent) and public schools (49 percent) care “a lot.” Approximately three in ten Latinos say each level of government (local, state, and federal) cares a lot about the fight against AIDS.

 

1392-fig4

 

Almost half (45 percent) of Latinos say local health care providers are doing “a lot” to help fight AIDS. About a third say local public schools (33 percent) and local churches (31 percent) are doing “a lot.” And approximately one in four Latinos say government – local (23 percent), state (24 percent), and federal (24 percent) – is doing “a lot” to help fight against AIDS. Latinos are more likely than the general public to say the church cares “a lot” in the fight against AIDS compared to 39 percent of the general public. Thirty-one percent of Latinos also say the church is doing “a lot” to help fight AIDS compared to 18 percent of the general public.

MOST KNOW THE BASICS ABOUT HIV/AIDS, BUT IMPORTANT KNOWLEDGE GAPS EXISTMost Latinos know that AIDS is sexually transmitted (98 percent) and that a woman with HIV can give it to her baby (92 percent). Eighty-two percent, know that there are drugs available which can lengthen the life of a person infected with AIDS. Fewer, 55 percent, know that a pregnant woman with HIV can take steps to reduce the risk of transmitting it to her baby.

 

1392-fig5

While 68 percent of Latinos know that there is no vaccine available to protect a person from getting AIDS, one in five (20 percent) incorrectly believes that a vaccine is available (compared to 5 percent of the general public). And although 77 percent says there is no cure for AIDS, another 20 percent mistakenly believes there is a cure (compared to 11 percent of the general public).

Most Latinos (92 percent) agree with the statement that, “by now, adults in this country should know how to protect themselves from HIV.” Seventy-seven percent says that adults who become infected today should be held more personally responsible than those infected years ago. One in two Latinos (50 percent) says that adults who become infected with HIV today should have to pay more of their medical bills themselves than those who were infected years ago (compared to 42 percent of all the general public).

OPTIMISM ABOUT NEW TREATMENTSLatinos appear slightly more optimistic than the general public about the amount of progress that has been made in treating HIV and AIDS. Nearly one in two Latinos (49 percent) say “a lot” of progress has been made in keeping people who have AIDS alive longer, compared to 44 percent of the general public.

 

1392-fig6

And two in five Latinos (43 percent) say “a lot” of progress has been made in finding a cure for AIDS, compared to 28 percent of the general public.

Latinos are more likely than the general public to believe the new drugs are effective for most people with HIV and widely available to those who want them. More than one in three Latinos (36 percent) say the new combination drugs are effective in helping most or nearly all of those who take them (compared to 25 percent of the general public). And 30 percent say most or nearly all of those who want the new drug treatments actually get them (12 percent of the general public holds this view).

LATINOS SUPPORTIVE OF FEDERAL SPENDING ON AIDSLatinos are very supportive of spending to prevent, treat and research HIV and AIDS. Most Latinos favor spending for research to find more effective AIDS treatments (95 percent) as well as to find an AIDS vaccine (94 percent). And nine in ten favor spending on HIV and AIDS education and other prevention activities as well as spending to make the new combination drug treatments available to more people (both 94 percent). Asked to rank these spending areas in order of priority, vaccine research is ranked first (43 percent) and education/prevention is number two (33 percent).

Forty-four percent of Latinos say the federal government spends too little on AIDS and 31 percent say spending is about right. Seventeen percent say spending on AIDS is too high. And when asked about federal spending on AIDS compared to other health problems, such as heart disease and cancer, about one third of Latinos (35 percent) say spending on AIDS is too low, 17 percent say spending is too high, and 37 percent say it is about right.

 

1392-fig7

INFORMATION NEEDSLatinos cite greater needs for information about HIV/AIDS than the general public.

  • Seven out of ten (70 percent) want more information about what to discuss with children about HIV and AIDS, which is much higher than the general public (46 percent).
  • Sixty-three percent say they need information about where to go for help if exposed to HIV (compared to 38 percent of the general public).
  • More than half of all Latinos (58 percent) want more information about testing for HIV (compared to 32 percent of the general public).
  • One in two (51 percent) want to know what to discuss with partners about sex (compared to 22 percent of the general public); and
  • Two in five (41 percent) would like information about the proper way to use condoms (compared to 13 percent of the general public).

When asked which ONE area was most important to get more information in, discussing AIDS with children (40 percent) and getting information about where to go for help if exposed to HIV (17 percent) were ranked highest.

1392-fig8

 

MEDIA AND OTHER INFORMATION SOURCESLatinos see a role for television and other media in the fight against AIDS. Most Latinos (71 percent) say that major television networks should accept advertising from condom manufacturers for broadcast (compared to 62 percent of the general public). A majority of Latinos (59 percent) favor more condom references in movies and shows that deal with sexual relationships (compared to 55 percent of the general public).

Television is the number one source of HIV/AIDS information according to Latinos. Seven in ten (70 percent) say they got information about AIDS in the last month from television news programs (compared to 56 percent of the general public). Two in five (44 percent) say they got information from television entertainment shows (compared to 25 percent of the general public).

 

1392-fig9

Radio is also a significant information source: 42 percent say they got information from radio talk or call in shows in the last month (compared to 26 percent of the general public) and 34 percent say they got information from “other radio programming” (compared to 17 percent of the general public).

More than one in three Latinos (39 percent) say they received information about AIDS from street signs or billboards (compared to 21 percent of the general public), 28 percent from family members, friends or acquaintances (compared to 20 percent of the general public), and 32 percent from their doctor or another health care provider (compared to 18 percent of the general public). One in five Latinos (20 percent) say they received information about HIV/AIDS from their church or a local religious group (compared to 10 percent of the general public).

Ten percent of Latinos said they didn’t get information about HIV/AIDS from any of the sources in the past month (see special section on Language for differences by language of interview). Latinos report higher levels of consumption of news about HIV and AIDS than the general public. One in three Latinos (37 percent) say they saw or heard “a lot” of news about HIV/AIDS on television, radio, in newspapers and other media in the past year and 23 percent say they heard or saw a lot of news about the new combination drug treatments, in particular. By comparison, 21 percent of the general public has seen or heard a lot of news about HIV/AIDS, 11 percent about combination drug treatments, in particular.

One in two Latinos (50 percent) say recent news coverage gives people the impression that AIDS is a more urgent problem today than it was a few years ago (compared to 28 percent of the general public). One in five Latinos (20 percent) say news coverage depicts AIDS as less urgent.

NEEDLE EXCHANGESlightly more than half of Latinos (56 percent) favor “needle exchange programs which offer clean needles to IV drug users in exchange for used ones, to help stop the spread of HIV,” (compared to 58 percent of the general public).

Similar to the general public, when offered an argument voiced by opponents of needle exchange, namely that these programs might give tacit approval of illegal drug use, support drops among Latinos: 41 percent favor, 56 percent oppose.

HIV TESTINGAs noted earlier, two in five Latinos (42 percent) have tested for HIV, 23 percent in the last year. More than half (58 percent) say they discussed the results of their tests with a doctor or other medical professional or counselor (compared to 50 percent of the general public).

Among those who have never tested for HIV, most say it is because they are married or in a monogamous relationship (42 percent), they are not sexually active (19 percent) or there is no need/reason to suspect a problem (9 percent). Fifteen percent say they don’t know why they haven’t tested or decline to give a reason.

More than two-thirds of Latinos (69 percent) have never talked with a health care provider about any aspect of HIV or AIDS. Just three in ten have ever discussed HIV/AIDS with a health care provider (31 percent) – one quarter (24 percent) have talked specifically about the risks of being infected with HIV and one in five (19 percent) have discussed getting tested.

Of the small group who have had conversations occur, the majority say they brought up the topic as opposed to their health care provider raising the issue – 52 percent brought up the risks of HIV infection and 58 percent raised the issue of testing with their provider.

Language and Perceptions of HIV/AIDS

The Kaiser Family Foundation National Survey of Latinos on HIV/AIDS was administered in both English and Spanish. Half the surveys were administered in Spanish, half in English. Our analysis of responses demonstrates that perceptions of and attitudes toward HIV/AIDS among Latinos vary by language of interview. These differences may be attributed to many factors including:

  • Level of acculturation. Language is one component of acculturation, a measure of the strength of values from country of origin. Acculturation may be associated with disease risk. 18
  • Access to information and prevention initiatives. Fewer AIDS education and prevention materials are provided in languages other than English and non-English speaking individuals may have more difficulty accessing prevention and care programs.
  • Socioeconomic factors. Income, education, and religion, for example, may be related to language and these socioeconomic factors may influence attitudes and opinions.
  • Survey translation. The Spanish language version of the survey may convey different kinds of meanings and messages to survey respondents and/or Spanish speaking Latinos may respond to surveys differently.

 

1392-fig10

The profile of those interviewed in Spanish is as follows:

  • Latinos interviewed in Spanish are less educated than Latinos interviewed in English. Almost two-thirds (63 percent) have less than a high school education compared to 23 percent of Latinos interviewed in English.
  • They are older than those interviewed in English. Whereas 40 percent of those interviewed in English were between 18 and 29 years old, 26 percent of those interviewed in Spanish were in this age range.
  • They are slightly more likely to be of Mexican ancestry (63 percent of those interviewed in Spanish compared to 58 percent of those interviewed in English) and less likely to be of Puerto Rican ancestry (5 percent compared to 15 percent);
  • Latinos interviewed in Spanish are more likely to be Catholic (84 percent compared to 66 percent of those interviewed in English).

Latinos interviewed in Spanish expressed a greater sense of urgency about AIDS.

  • Over half (53 percent) rate AIDS as the most urgent health problem in the country today, compared to 46 percent of those interviewed in English.
  • They are also more likely to say the problem of AIDS is more urgent today than a few years ago (73 percent compared to 61 percent).
  • Latinos interviewed in Spanish are more likely to say that the country is losing ground in the fight against AIDS (40 percent compared to 25 percent of those interviewed in English).
  • Finally, Latinos interviewed in Spanish express a greater sense of the impact of AIDS on their local communities. They are almost twice as likely to say the problem of AIDS in their local communities is more urgent today (65 percent compared to 37 percent of Latinos interviewed in English).

In addition, Latinos interviewed in Spanish express greater personal concern about HIV.

  • Most of those interviewed in Spanish (80 percent) say that AIDS is a very serious problem for those they know, compared to 53 percent of those interviewed in English.
  • They are also more likely to be very concerned about becoming infected with HIV (51 percent compared to 41 percent) and are more likely to be more concerned today than a few years ago (46 percent compared to 37 percent).
  • Despite the heightened sense of urgency and personal concern, Latinos interviewed in Spanish are less likely to say they know someone who has AIDS, has died from AIDS or has tested positive for HIV (28 percent compared to 42 percent of those interviewed in English).

Concern about children becoming infected with HIV among Latinos also appears to be related to language.

  • Those interviewed in Spanish are more likely to be parents (60 percent compared to 48 percent).
  • They are slightly more likely to be concerned about their kids becoming infected with HIV (73 percent compared to 68 percent of those interviewed in English) but concern is high among all Latinos.
  • Latinos interviewed in Spanish are also more likely to be more concerned about their kids becoming infected today than they were a few years ago (62 percent compared to 53 percent).

Knowledge about AIDS appears to be related to language of interview in a couple of areas.

  • Latinos interviewed in Spanish are more than twice as likely to incorrectly state that there is an AIDS vaccine (28 percent compared to 11 percent of those interviewed in English).
  • They are also less likely to know that there is no cure for AIDS (72 percent of those interviewed in Spanish compared to 82 percent of those interviewed in English).
  • But Latinos interviewed in Spanish are more likely to know that a pregnant woman with HIV can transmit the virus to her baby (95 percent compared to 89 percent of those interviewed in English) and that a pregnant woman with HIV can take steps to reduce the risk to her baby (62 percent compared to 49 percent). Latinos interviewed in Spanish cite much greater information needs.
  • Latinos interviewed in Spanish cite greater information needs across the board. For example, Latinos interviewed in Spanish are more than twice as likely (60 percent compared to 24 percent of Latinos interviewed in English) to say they want information about the proper way to use condoms.
  • They are also much more likely to say they want information about discussing sex with partners (61 percent compared to 41 percent).
1392-fig111392-fig12

Sources of AIDS Information also vary by language of interview.

  • Latinos interviewed in Spanish are more likely to have received AIDS information from TV news programs, TV entertainment programs, radio, and church.
  • Latinos interviewed in English are more likely to have received information from newspapers, magazines, and the workplace.
  • In addition, those interviewed in Spanish are less likely to have talked with a provider about HIV, about HIV/AIDS risks, and about getting tested.
1392-fig13

 

Regional Location and Perceptions of HIV/AIDS among Latinos

The US Latino population is concentrated primarily in the West (43 percent) and the South (33 percent) with 16 percent of Latinos residing in the Northeast and 7 percent in the Midwest. Most of the Latino population (87 percent) resides in 10 states – California, Texas, New York, Florida, Illinois, New Jersey, Arizona, New Mexico, Colorado, and Massachusetts – which include many of the major AIDS epicenters in the US. 19

The distribution of the US Latino population across the country is highly correlated with country of origin. 20 The distribution of country of origin among those surveyed, which approximates the US Latino population overall, is as follows: 60 percent of Mexican ancestry, 10 percent of Puerto Rican ancestry, 7 percent of Cuban ancestry, 5 percent of Dominican ancestry, and 17 percent Latinos of other ancestries (other Central/South American or Spanish).

The AIDS epidemic among Latinos in the US is concentrated in the Northeast, where Puerto Ricans and Dominicans are most likely to live. Latinos living in the West and South, primarily of Mexican and Cuban ancestry, have a lower incidence of HIV. Higher incidence of HIV in the Northeast among Puerto Rican and Dominican Latinos may be related to higher use of injection drugs. Puerto Rican Latinos have the highest prevalence of drug use, in part due to the fact that most (70 percent) living in the US reside in New York City, New Jersey, and Chicago, areas which have greater availability of illegal drugs. 21 AIDS case rates per 100,000 population among Latinos are highest in the Northeastern States, including: New York (142.3), New Jersey (69.0), Pennsylvania (115.4), Rhode Island (58.8), Massachusetts (91.3), and Delaware (87.8). 22

Although the sample size did not allow for an analysis of perceptions of AIDS by ethnicity/country of origin, we were able to analyze perceptions by region. 23 Latinos living in the Northeast and the West are more likely to have been interviewed in Spanish (53 percent and 56 percent respectively). Latinos living in the South are more likely to have been interviewed in English (60 percent).

Latinos living in all regions of the US express urgency about AIDS with some regions expressing greater urgency

  • .
  • The sense of urgency about the AIDS epidemic appears to be greatest in the Northeast. Latinos in the Northeast are more likely to say AIDS is the most urgent health problem facing the nation today (59 percent compared to 49 percent of those in the West and 45 percent of those in the South).

Personal experience with AIDS varies somewhat by region and may in part reflect the epidemiology of HIV/AIDS.

  • In terms of the severity of the problem of AIDS for people they know, there are some regional differences among Latinos. Seventy-one percent of Latinos in the Northeast say AIDS is a very serious problem for those they know compared to 68 percent of those in the West and 62 percent of those in the South.
  • Latinos in the Northeast are much more likely to know someone who has AIDS, has died from AIDS, or has tested positive for HIV. Fifty-six percent of those in the Northeast know someone compared to 30 percent of those in the West and 32 percent of those in the South.

Personal concern about becoming infected with HIV follows similar regional patterns among Latinos.

  • Personal concern about becoming infected with HIV is roughly similar across the country although more than half of those in the Northeast (51 percent) say they are very concerned about becoming infected with HIV. Forty-four percent of Latinos in the West and 46 percent of Latinos in the South say they are very concerned about becoming infected with HIV.
  • Latinos in the Northeast are more likely to have been tested for HIV. Over half of those in the Northeast (51 percent) have ever tested compared to 41 percent of those in the West and 43 percent of those in the South.

AIDS knowledge also varies somewhat by region.

  • In particular, knowledge that there are drugs available to lengthen the life of those with HIV is highest in the Northeast (88 percent compared to 76 percent of those in the South and 84 percent of those in the West).
  • Knowledge that a pregnant woman with AIDS can give it to her baby is highest among Latinos in the South (94 percent compared to 87 percent of Latinos in the Northeast and 93 percent of Latinos in the West).
  • Knowledge that a pregnant woman with HIV can take certain steps to reduce the risks to her baby also varies by regions (74 percent of those in the Northeast compared to 58 percent of those in the West and 45 percent of those in the South).
1392-fig14

While stated information needs are similar across regions, there are some differences in AIDS information sources.

  • For example, Latinos in the South are less likely to have received AIDS information from the radio (32 percent) compared to those in the Northeast (45 percent) and West (41 percent). Latinos in the Northeast are more likely to have received AIDS information from newspapers (53 percent) than those in the West (43 percent).
  • Latinos in the Northeast are also more likely to have talked with a provider about HIV/AIDS (43 percent compared to 33 percent of those in the South and 27 percent of those in the West).
  • Support for condom references on TV also varies by region. There is much more support in the Northeast for condom references on television shows (70 percent compared to 56 percent of Latinos in the West and 58 percent of Latinos in the South).

 

1392-fig15

 

Income, Education and Attitudes Towards/Knowledge of HIV/AIDS Among Latinos

Income and education may play a role in the disproportionate impact of HIV infection on certain populations. In addition, new research indicates that those with less education are significantly less likely to have access to important and cost-effec-tive drugs needed to prevent AIDS-related opportunistic infections, such as Pneumocystis Carinii Pneumonia. 24

Risk may be compounded for Latinos who are disproportionately poor and, on average, have lower educational attainment relative to the US population overall. Approximately 30 percent of all Latinos live in poverty and only 53 percent, compared to 83 percent of the general public, have a high school degree or more. We analyzed perceptions of the AIDS epidemic among Latinos who have less than a high school education (43 percent) and earn less than $20,000 per year (47 percent). There is significant overlap between these subpopulations. Close to two thirds (62 percent) of those with less than a high school education earn less than $20,000 per year and over half (56 percent) of those with less than $20,000 income also have less than a high school education.

Latinos with less than a high school education are much more likely to have been interviewed in Spanish (72 percent) than English (28 percent) as are Latinos who earn less than $20,000 per year (69 percent were interviewed in Spanish and 31 percent were interviewed in English).

Latinos with less education and lower incomes share a sense of urgency about AIDS with Latinos overall.

  • Over half (52 percent) of Latinos with less than a high school education and 50 percent of Latinos who earn less than $20,000 per year say that AIDS is the most urgent health problem in the country today, as do half of all Latinos. Most (95 percent of Latinos with less education and 93 percent of Latinos with lower incomes) say that AIDS is a major public health threat.
  • Latinos with less education are more likely to say that the country is losing ground in the fight against AIDS (40 percent compared to 32 percent of all Latinos) and less likely to say the country is making progress (37 percent compared to 44 percent of all).
  • Thirty-five percent of Latinos with lower incomes say the country is losing ground in the fight against AIDS, while 40 percent say the country is making progress.
  • Latinos with lower incomes are more likely to say that AIDS is a more urgent problem for their local community (60 percent compared to 52 percent of all Latinos and 55 percent of those with less education).
1392-fig16

There is greater personal concern about AIDS among Latinos with less education and lower incomes.

  • Latinos with less than a high school education and those with lower incomes are more likely to say AIDS is a very serious problem for people they know (78 percent and 73 percent respectively, compared to 67 percent of all Latinos).
  • Personal concern about becoming infected with HIV is slightly higher among these subpopulations; 53 percent of Latinos with less education are very concerned compared to 46 percent of all Latinos and they are more likely to be more concerned today (49 percent compared to 42 percent of all Latinos). Half (50 percent) of Latinos with lower incomes are very concerned about becoming infected with HIV and 44 percent are more concerned today.
  • Testing rates are slightly lower among Latinos with less than high school education (36 percent compared to 43 percent of Latinos with lower incomes and 42 percent of all Latinos).

Perceptions of government and community group activity in the fight against AIDS appear to vary by education and income.

  • Latinos with less education are more likely to say each group is doing a lot in fight against AIDS and more likely to say each group cares a lot than are Latinos overall.
  • Latinos with lower incomes are more likely to say each group is doing a lot in the fight against AIDS than are Latinos overall. There are somewhat different levels of knowledge among Latinos with less education.
  • Latinos with less education are more likely to incorrectly state that there is an AIDS vaccine (32 percent compared to 24 percent of those with lower incomes and 20 percent of all Latinos) and are less likely to know there is no cure for AIDS (69 percent compared to 74 percent of those with lower incomes and 77 percent of all).
1392-fig17

Latinos with less education and lower incomes cite greater information needs than Latinos overall.

  • They are more likely to want information about the proper way to use condoms, what to discuss with partners about sex, talking with children about AIDS prevention, testing, and where to go for help if exposed to HIV.

Latinos with less education receive AIDS information from different sources.

  • For example, Latinos with less education are less likely to receive AIDS information from newspapers (39 percent compared to 46 percent of all Latinos) and magazines (36 percent compared to 48 percent).
  • In addition, those with less education are slightly less likely to have talked with a provider about AIDS (24 percent compared to 27 percent of those with lower incomes and 31 percent of all Latinos), about risks of HIV (19 percent compared to 22 percent of those with lower incomes and 25 percent of all), and getting tested for HIV (15 percent compared to 17 percent of those with lower incomes and 19 percent of all).

Religion and Perceptions of HIV/AIDS among Latinos

Religion may be related to perceptions of HIV/AIDS and risk behaviors. For example, religion may influence attitudes about gender roles, sex, sexuality, and condom use. Most Latinos identify as Catholic (75 percent), which differs from the US population overall (24 percent identify as Catholic). Eighteen percent of Latinos identify as Protestant compared to almost two-thirds (63 percent) of the US population overall. Catholic Latinos are more likely to have been interviewed in Spanish (55 percent) than English. Protestant Latinos are more likely to have been interviewed in English (72 percent).

Urgency about AIDS varies slightly by religion.

  • Over half of Catholic Latinos (52 percent) say that AIDS is the most urgent health problem in the country today, compared to 45 percent of Protestant Latinos.

Similarly, the sense of concern for those they know and personal concern about AIDS appear to be related to religion.

  • Catholic Latinos are more likely to say AIDS is very serious for people they know (69 percent compared to 61 percent of Protestant Latinos).
  • Almost half of Catholic Latinos (49 percent) are very concerned about becoming infected with HIV, compared to 35 percent of Protestant Latinos.
  • Catholic Latinos are more concerned about becoming infected today than they were a few years ago (43 percent compared to 33 percent of Protestant Latinos).
  • Despite the greater expressed concern about AIDS among Catholic Latinos, they are slightly less likely than Protestant Latinos to report knowing someone who has HIV, AIDS, or has died of AIDS (34 percent compared to 41 percent of Protestant Latinos).

Support for government spending is high among Latinos of all religions, with Catholic Latinos being the most supportive.

  • Almost all Catholic Latinos (96 percent) support spending on AIDS edu cation and prevention activities compared to 87 percent of Protestant Latinos.
  • Ninetysix percent of Catholic Latinos support spending on AIDS vaccine research compared to 85 percent of Protestant Latinos.
  • And 87 percent of Catholic Latinos believe that the government should be spending money to help HIV infected people with lower incomes pay for new treatments compared to 64 percent of Protestant Latinos.

Support for condom advertising and references on TV also varies by religion, but is generally high.

  • Catholic Latinos are much more supportive of condom advertising (74 percent compared to 56 percent of Protestant Latinos) and more references to condoms on TV programs (62 percent compared to 47 percent of Protestant Latinos).
1392-fig18

Desire for information among Latinos differs by religion, although there are few differences in information sources.

  • Catholic Latinos state greater information needs in all areas compared to Protestant Latinos. For example, 46 percent of Catholic Latinos compared to 27 percent of Protestant Latinos want more information about the proper way to use condoms.
  • Sources of information generally appear to be the same with a couple of exceptions. Catholic Latinos are more likely (48 percent) than Protestant Latinos (37 percent) to say they received AIDS information from newspapers, and more likely to have received AIDS information from radio programming (not talk or callin) than Protestant Latinos (35 percent of Catholic Latinos compared to 27 percent of Protestant Latinos).
  • Finally, perceptions of news coverage about AIDS vary. Catholic Latinos are more likely to say news coverage gives the impression that AIDS is more urgent today (53 percent compared to 38 percent of Protestant Latinos).

Latinas and HIV/AIDS

Latina women (Latinas) have been disproportionately impacted by HIV/AIDS. Latinas represent 20 percent of all reported AIDS cases and 19 percent of new cases among women 25 but only comprise 10 percent of the female population. 26 The AIDS case rate (standardized to population size) among Latinas is six times that of non-Hispanic white women (23.0 compared to 3.8 per 100,000). 27 Heterosexual transmission of HIV accounts for most cases of AIDS among Latinas (47 percent of new cases) and the proportion of AIDS cases among Latinas today due to heterosexual transmission has been steadily increasing. As such, heterosexual transmission plays a greater role in HIV transmission among Latinas today than among women overall (40 percent), white non-Hispanic women (40 percent), and Black non-Hispanic women (38 percent). HIV infection due to injection drug use is the primary mode of transmission in one third of new AIDS cases (33 percent).

Half of Latina respondents (50 percent) were interviewed in Spanish, as were half of Latino men. Their attitudes about and knowledge of HIV/AIDS are presented below:

A majority of Latinas view AIDS as the most urgent health problem facing the nation today, slightly more than Latino men and more than US women overall.

  • Fifty-two percent of Latinas, compared to 47 percent of Latino men, rate AIDS as the most urgent health problem facing the nation today. Cancer is rated most urgent by half as many Latinas (26 percent). By comparison, the plurality of women overall rate cancer as their top concern (42 percent), followed by AIDS (38 percent).
  • Two thirds of Latinas (67 percent) say that AIDS is a more urgent problem today, and 9 in 10 Latinas (91 percent) say AIDS is a major threat to public health today.

Latinas are concerned about AIDS in their local communities.

  • Half (50 percent) of all Latinas say that the problem of AIDS facing their local community is more urgent today.
  • Twenty-nine percent of Latinas say their local community is making progress in the fight against AIDS while 21 percent say that their local community is losing ground.
  • Latinas are less likely than Latino men (17 percent compared to 26 percent) to say that AIDS has never been a problem for the local community.

In addition, AIDS has affected Latinas personally, in terms of concern for people they know and their own concern about becoming infected.

  • Seven out of ten (70 percent) Latinas say that AIDS is a very serious problem for people they know, which is slightly more than Latino men (64 percent) and much greater than women overall (35 percent).
  • Slightly more than a third (37 percent) of Latinas say they know someone who has HIV, AIDS, or has died of AIDS.
  • Forty-five percent of Latinas are very concerned about becoming infected with HIV and many say they are more concerned today than a few years ago (43 percent). By comparison, 28 percent of all women are very concerned about becoming infected with HIV.

Almost all Latinas express concern about their children becoming infected with HIV.

  • About 7 in 10 mothers (69 percent) are very concerned about their children becoming infected with HIV. Another 16 percent are somewhat concerned.
  • A majority (56 percent) are more concerned about their children becoming infected today than they were a few years ago.

Despite personal concern about HIV, less than half of Latinas have ever been tested for HIV and most have never talked with a provider about HIV/AIDS.

  • Forty-three percent of Latinas have been tested for HIV, with 24 percent having tested in the past year.
  • Two thirds of Latinas (66 percent) have never talked with a provider about HIV/AIDS.
  • Among those who have tested for HIV, 60 percent report discussing the results with a provider.

Why have more than half (57 percent) of all Latinas not been tested for HIV?

  • Among those who have not tested, 24 percent say it is because they are not sexually active.
  • Forty-two percent say it is because they are married or in monogamous relationships.
1392-fig19

 

1392-fig20

 

1392-fig21

Latinas cite similar information needs as Latino men.

  • Overall, Latinas cite similar levels of information needs as Latino men including wanting more information on condom use, talking with partners about sex, and HIV testing.
  • Latinas are slightly more likely to say they want information about talking with kids about AIDS (73 percent of Latinas compared to 66 percent of Latino men).
  • Information about talking with kids about AIDS is Latinas’ highest ranked information need (42 percent).

In general, Latinas have received slightly less information about AIDS across most sources compared to Latino men.

  • For example, forty-one percent of Latinas say they have received AIDS information from TV entertainment programs in the past month compared to 47 percent of Latino men and 38 percent say they have received information from radio shows compared to 45 percent of men.
  • Indeed, Latinas are, across the board, more likely than Latino men to say they have not received AIDS information from most sources.

Latino Parents and HIV/AIDS

Attitudes of Latino parents toward HIV/AIDS are similar to those of Latinos in general and to parents overall. Over half (54 percent) of Latinos are parents of children 21 and younger.

  • Seven out of every 10 Latino parents (70 percent) are very concerned about their son or daughter becoming infected with HIV.
  • Over half (58 percent) of Latino parents are more concerned today than they were a few years ago.
  • Almost all Latino parents believe that the federal government should spend money on HIV and AIDS education and other prevention efforts (95 percent).
  • More than three quarters of Latino parents (76 percent) say they need information about discussing AIDS prevention with children. Parents rate this as their most important information need (46 percent).
  • Most Latino parents think that major television networks should accept advertising from condom manufacturers for broadcast (70 percent) and are very supportive of movies and television shows which deal with sexual relationships having more references to condom use (60 percent).

Younger Latinos and HIV/AIDS

The number of HIV infections continues to rise among young people and young people of color may even be at higher risk for HIV infection. One in every four Americans newly infected with HIV is under the age of 22 28 and almost two thirds (63 percent) of all reported AIDS cases among 20 to 24-year-olds are among people of color. 29 Twenty-one percent of all cases among 20 to 24-year-old males and 21 percent of cases among 20 to 24-year-old females are among Latinos/as. We know that young people engage in sexual and drug using behaviors that put them at risk; for example, 53 percent of high school students report being sexually active. 30

The relative youth of the Latino population may be related to HIV risk among Latinos. The median age of Latinos in the US is 26.5 years compared to 33.9 years for the US population overall. 31 We looked at the perceptions of AIDS among younger Latinos, 18 to 24 years old, who represent approximately 19 percent of the Latino population. Latinos ages 18 to 24 are more likely to have been interviewed in English (71 percent) than in Spanish (29 percent).

The sense of urgency about the AIDS epidemic is heightened among younger Latinos.

  • More younger Latinos think AIDS is the most urgent health problem today (59 percent compared to 50 percent of Latinos of all ages and 49 percent of all young people)
  • Most consider AIDS a major threat to the country’s public health (92 percent).

Younger Latinos express concern about AIDS for people they know.

  • More than half of younger Latinos say that AIDS is a very serious problem for people they know (57 percent). By comparison, 39 percent of all 18 to 24-year-olds say AIDS is a very serious problem for people they know.
  • One third of younger Latinos (33 percent) know someone who has HIV, AIDS, or has died of AIDS.
1392-fig22

 

1392-fig23

And younger Latinos are very concerned about becoming infected with HIV, more so than young adults overall.

  • Almost half of younger Latinos (49 percent) are very concerned about becoming infected with HIV, compared to less than a third (30 percent) of all 18 to 24-year-olds.
  • Forty-seven percent of younger Latinos are more concerned about becoming infected today than they were a few years ago.

Have younger Latinos been tested for HIV?

  • Less than half of younger Latinos have been tested.
  • Testing rates among younger Latinos are similar to those of Latinos over-all, with 42 percent of younger Latinos (and Latinos overall) ever testing.
  • Testing rates among younger Latinos are slightly lower than rates among all 18 to 24-year-olds (48 percent).

Overall, AIDS knowledge among younger Latinos is high.

  • Knowledge levels among younger Latinos appear to be greater in some areas compared to Latinos overall. For example, younger Latinos are slightly more likely to know that there are drugs available to lengthen the life of people with HIV (86 percent compared to 82 percent of all Latinos) and that there is no AIDS vaccine (77 percent compared to 69 percent of all Latinos).
1392-fig24

Younger Latinos cite fewer information needs across the board and are more likely to have received AIDS information than Latinos overall.

  • Younger Latinos cite less need for AIDS information than Latinos of all ages. For example, only 30 percent of younger Latinos cite a need for information about condom use compared to 41 percent of Latinos overall and 51 percent say they want information about HIV testing (compared to 58 percent of all Latinos).
  • Younger Latinos are more likely to say they have received AIDS information from a variety of sources, including TV news programs, magazines, and family and friends.
  • In addition, more young Latinos have talked with health care providers about HIV (41 percent compared to 31 percent of all Latinos), about the risks of HIV (34 percent compared to 25 percent) and about getting tested for HIV (26 percent compared to 19 percent).
  • Finally, younger Latinos are more supportive of condom advertising on TV (78 percent compared to 71 percent) and condom references on TV programs (70 percent compared to 59 percent) than are Latinos overall.

HIV/AIDS and Local Opinion Leaders in the Latino Community

What makes them local opinion leaders?

They are opinion leaders because in the past 12 months, they have participated in at least three of the following activities:

  • Attended a public meeting on town or school affairs (78 percent);
  • Helped organize a group or event in support of a cause (73 percent);
  • Served as an officer of some club or organization (66 percent);
  • Served on a local committee, such as a school board or community council (50 percent)
  • Made a public speech (40 percent);
  • Contacted members of Congress or a US Senator (36 percent);
  • Were interviewed or quoted by the media about an important issue (34 percent);
  • Worked on a political campaign (31 percent);
  • Wrote a letter to a newspaper that was published (21 percent).

Who are local opinion leaders?

  • Latino opinion leaders represent 11 percent of the Latino sample.
  • They are more educated than Latinos overall; more than half (59 percent) have some college education or more. Only 28 percent of Latinos overall have some college education or more.
  • Opinion leaders also earn significantly more than Latinos overall, with 41 percent reporting incomes of $40,000 or more. Only 14 percent of Latinos overall fall into this category.
  • Most opinion leaders are from the West (41 percent) or the South (37 percent). Seventeen percent are from the Northeast and 5 percent are from the Midwest. This distribution is similar to Latinos overall.
  • Latino opinion leaders have similar ethnic and religious distributions as Latinos overall.
  • Finally, Latino opinion leaders are more likely to be Democrats (48 percent compared to 38 percent of Latinos overall) and are as likely to be Republican (15 percent of opinion leaders and Latinos overall).

Given their role in Latino communities, how do their attitudes toward and knowledge of HIV/AIDS com pare to Latinos in general?

Latino opinion leaders rate AIDS as the most urgent health problem facing the nation today.

  • Forty-four percent of opinion leaders say AIDS is the most urgent health problem.
  • Eight in ten (82 percent) say AIDS is a major public health threat, although this is slightly less than Latinos overall (91 percent). Personal concern about AIDS is less among Opinion Leaders.
  • Opinion leaders are less likely to say AIDS is a very serious problem for those they know (55 percent compared to 67 percent of all Latinos).
  • Opinion leaders express less personal concern about becoming infected with HIV (33 percent are very concerned compared to 46 percent of all Latinos).
  • They are also less likely to say their concern about becoming infected has grown over the past few years (30 percent compared to 41 percent of all Latinos).
  • On the other hand, opinion leaders are more personally touched by HIV/AIDS, given that over half (54 percent) say they know someone who has HIV, AIDS, or has died of AIDS compared to 35 percent of Latinos overall.
  • Opinion leaders are slightly more likely to have been tested for HIV (51 percent compared to 42 percent of all Latinos). Support for spending is high across the board, although opinion leaders are slightly less likely than Latinos overall to support spending in some areas.
  • Eighty-seven percent of opinion leaders, for example, support spending to make new treatments available, compared to 94 percent of all Latinos. Ninety percent support spending on HIV/AIDS education and prevention programs (compared to 94 percent of all Latinos).

IMPLICATIONS OF SURVEY FINDINGSThe Kaiser Family Foundation Survey of Latinos on HIV/AIDS provides new data on Latinos’ perceptions, knowledge, and information needs regarding HIV/AIDS which may offer direction for continued efforts to address the HIV/AIDS epidemic within the Latino community. In particular, the survey finds Latinos to be very worried about the scope of the epidemic nationally and at the local level. Latinos view HIV/AIDS as a more urgent problem today than just a few years ago. Latinos also experience HIV/AIDS close to home: many report knowing someone with HIV and most express worry for themselves as well as their children and people they know.

Despite heightened worry, Latinos express higher levels of optimism about progress in the epidemic compared to the general public. Many Latinos say there has been a lot of progress in treating and preventing HIV/AIDS and more than half say a lot of progress has been made towards finding a cure. Latinos give higher marks to local community groups than government in terms of how much they care about and actually do in the fight against AIDS. Still, there is room for more action.

Latinos express high expectations for personal responsibility in preventing the transmission of HIV and are eager for more information relating to preventing the spread of AIDS. In fact, Latinos are more likely than the general public to say they want more information across a variety of topics related to HIV/AIDS. In particular, Latinos voice the need for more information about talking to children about HIV/AIDS, as well as discussing sex with partners, where to go for help if exposed to HIV, and HIV testing. And two in five Latinos cite the need for information about the proper use of condoms.

There are important differences in information sources about HIV/AIDS among Latinos compared to the general public. For example, television and radio play a much greater role, as do street signs and billboards. Latinos also get more information about HIV/AIDS from churches and religious organizations.

Additionally, the survey reveals differences in perceptions, knowledge and information sources regarding HIV/AIDS within the Latino population. These differences appear to be related to language of interview, ethnicity/ region, income, education, religion, gender, and age, factors which have been identified by other researchers as playing a potentially important role in HIV risk and related behaviors and attitudes. 32 As such, our survey findings bolster existing recommendations for identifying information needs within subgroups of the Latino population and targeting interventions accordingly.

Endnotes1 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (1997). HIV/AIDS Surveillance Report, Midyear Edition, Vol. 9, No. 1.

2 Karon, J.M. et. al. (1996). “Prevalence of HIV Infection in the United States, 1984 to 1992,” Journal of the American Medical Association, Vol. 276, No. 2. For other estimates see P.S. Rosenberg, 1995 and S.D. Holmberg, 1996.

3 The term Latino is used herein to describe US residents of Hispanic origin, regardless of race. These designations are based on selfreport.

4 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (1982). Kaposi’s Sarcoma (KS), Pneumocyctis Carinii Pneumonia (PCP), and Other Opportunistic Infections (OI): Cases Reported to CDC as of June 15, 1982. First Report.

5 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (1997). HIV/AIDS Surveillance Report, Midyear Edition, Vol. 9, No. 1; U.S. Bureau of the Census. (1997). Statistical Abstract of the United States: 1997 (117th Edition). Washington, DC.

6 Karon, J.M. et. al. (1996). “Prevalence of HIV Infection in the United States, 1984 to 1992,” Journal of the American Medical Association, Vol. 276, No. 2.

7 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (1997). HIV/AIDS Surveillance Report, Midyear Edition, Vol. 9, No. 1. Note that HIV/AIDS Surveillance case data are reported for the United States and its territories, including Puerto Rico. Data from our survey include only those living in the continental US.

8 US Bureau of the Census. (1997). Statistical Abstract of the United States: 1997 (117th Edition). Washington, DC.

9 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for HIV, STD, & TB Prevention. 1996 data. For example, 142.3 in New York State compared to 22.9 in California.

10 Marin, B. and Gomez, C. (1994). Latinos, HIV Disease, and Culture: Strategies for HIV Prevention. The AIDS Knowledge Base, HIV InSite.

11 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (1997). HIV/AIDS Surveillance Report, Midyear Edition, Vol. 9, No. 1.

12 National Center for Health Statistics. (1997). Health, United States, 1996-1997 and Injury Chartbook. Hyattsville, Maryland. Deaths per 100,000 population for the 12 month period ending June 30, 1996.

13 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (1997). HIV/AIDS Surveillance Report, Midyear Edition, Vol. 9, No. 1.

14 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (1997). “Update: Trends in AIDS Incidence – United States, 1996”, Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, Volume 46, No. 37.

15 National Center for Health Statistics. (1997). Health, United States, 1996-1997 and Injury Chartbook. Hyattsville, Maryland.

16 Agency for Health Care Policy and Research and National Center for Health Statistics, Medical Expenditure Panel Survey. (May 1997). Health Insurance Status of the U.S. Civilian Noninstitutionalized Population, First half of 1996; Agency for Health Care Policy and Research and National Center for Health Statistics, Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (Oct. 1997). Access to Health Care in America , Estimates for U.S. Civilian Noninstitutionalized Population, First half of

17 Refers to the Kaiser Family Foundation 1997 National Survey of Americans on AIDS/HIV, a nationally representative sample of American adults, including representative proportions of minority respondents.

18 Peragallo, N. (1996). “Latino Women and AIDS Risk”, Public Health Nursing, Vol. 13, No. 3.

19 Marin, B. and Gomez, C. (1994). Latinos, HIV Disease, and Culture: Strategies for HIV Prevention. The AIDS Knowledge Base, HIV InSite.

20 Country of origin may include nationality and/or ethnic identity.

21 Marin, B. and Gomez, C. (1994). Latinos, HIV Disease, and Culture: Strategies for HIV Prevention. The AIDS Knowledge Base, HIV InSite.

22 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for HIV, STD, and TB Prevention. 1996 Data.

23 In addition, we were unable to analyze data for the Midwest due to the small number of Latinos sampled who live in the Midwest.

24 Preliminary Data from HIV Cost and Services Utilization Study (HCSUS). Personal communication, Drs. Martin Shapiro and Samuel Bozzette, February 1998.

25 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (1997). HIV/AIDS Surveillance Report, Midyear Edition Vol. 9, No.1.

26 U.S. Bureau of the Census. United States Population Estimates, by Age, Sex, Race, and Hispanic Origin, 1990-1996. Release PPL-57.

27 National Center for Health Statistics. (1997). Health, United States, 1996-97 and Injury Chartbook. Hyattsville, Maryland. Cases per 100,000 population for 12 month period ending June 30, 1996. 1996.

28 AIDS Research Institute, The Center for AIDS Prevention Studies, University of California and the Harvard AIDS Institute (1997). Dangerous Inhibitions: How America is Letting AIDS Become an Epidemic of the Young.

29 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (1997). HIV/AIDS Surveillance Report, Midyear Edition Vol. 9, No.1.

30 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1995 Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance System.

31 U.S. Bureau of the Census. Selected Social Characteristics of All Persons and Hispanic Persons, by Type of Origin: March 1996. Internet Release date: Frebruary 3, 1998.

32 Marin, B. and Gomez, C. (1994). Latinos, HIV Disease and Culture: Strategies for HIV Prevention. The AIDS Knowledge Base, HIV InSite; Peragallo, N. (1996). “Latino Women and AIDS Risk”, Public Health Nursing, Vol. 13, No. 3; Center for AIDS Prevention, UCSF Fact Sheet: What Are Latinos’ HIV Prevention Needs?;National Council of La Raza (1996). Center for Health Promotion HIV/AIDS Information Guide: HIV/STDs and Hispanic Women.

Return to top

Two New Studies On Latinos And AIDS In AmericaReport | Press Release | Library Index

Parents, Children and the Television Ratings System:  Two Kaiser Family Foundation Surveys

Published: Apr 29, 1998

New National Surveys of Parents and Children on TV Ratings System:

Half of Parents Use the New TV Ratings,But Many Say Changes Could Make Them More Helpful

Parents Also Need To Know More About How the System Works

Embargoed for release until 9:00 a.m. ET, Wednesday, May 27, 1998

1398-pdffile.gifThe Report is available in Adobe Acrobat Format

pdffile.gifThe Chart Pack is available in Adobe Acrobat Format

Contacts:Tina Hoff/Kaiser Family Foundation (415) 854-9400, orMatt James/Kaiser Family Foundation (415) 854-9400

Washington, DC – As the first television season using the new ratings system draws to a close, half of all parents with children ages 2-17 (54%) say they are using the new ratings to help guide their children’s viewing, and 45% say they have stopped at least one of their children from watching a particular show because of its rating, according to two new surveys of parents and children by the Kaiser Family Foundation. But more than eight out of ten parents who use the ratings say there are improvements that would make the ratings more helpful, and many do not have a good understanding of how the current system works.

The survey also finds that parental concerns about television content are rising. The number of parents of children ages 2-17 who say they are concerned “a great deal” that their children are being exposed to too much sexual content on TV increased from 43% in an October 1996 Kaiser Family Foundation survey to 67% in April, 1998, when this survey was conducted. The number expressing the same concern about violent content increased from 39% to 62% over the same period.

The TV ratings system was designed to help address concerns about television content by giving parents assistance in monitoring what their children watch. Nearly all of the parents who have ever used the ratings say they have found them “useful” (42% “very” and 51% “somewhat”). A smaller percentage of parents who use the system say the ratings have been “successful” in keeping children from being exposed to inappropriate material (13% “very” and 51% “somewhat”).

“Parents say they are more concerned than ever about the impact of TV on their kids,” said Drew Altman, President of the Kaiser Family Foundation. “The good news for the ratings system is that many parents are using the ratings and find them helpful; but they do not always understand the system, and there are changes they’d like to see made.”

One out of five parents say (18%) they have not heard about the ratings system. Twenty-seven percent of parents say they have heard of the ratings system but “never” or “hardly ever” use it. The most common reason given by these parents for not using the ratings is that they would rather decide for themselves what is appropriate or not for their children to watch (31% say this is the leading reason).

Many Children Also Use Ratings.

In a companion survey of children, a third (36%) of 10-17 year olds report that at least once, one of their parents has stopped them from watching a show because of its rating. The survey also revealed that just over a third (36%) of all children say they themselves have decided not to watch a particular show because of the rating it received. But children have mixed reasons for tuning out: forty percent say it is because their parents wouldn’t want them to watch the show, while 26% say it is because they think the show is meant for younger kids.

Parents Say Changes Could Make Ratings More Useful.

Most parents who use the ratings (73%) say they learn a show’s rating from seeing the symbol on-screen at the beginning of the show, but many (67%) say even when they are looking for the rating they miss seeing it. More than eight out of ten parents who use the ratings say they favor having the rating appear on screen more often (84%) or announced out loud at the beginning of the show (82%), but most do not favor having the rating stay on screen throughout the entire show (42% support, 57% oppose).

Many Parents Need More Information About Ratings.

The survey indicated that many parents could use more information about how the ratings system works, including what kinds of shows are rated, who rates programming, and what the different rating symbols mean. Even among those parents who are aware of the ratings system,

  • Less than half know that children’s shows (49%), talk shows (40%) and soap operas (23%) are rated.
  • About half (54%) know what at least six of the eleven rating symbols mean, while 46% know five or fewer.
  • Thirty-one percent know that the television industry rates programs itself, while 32% believe that an independent review board does the rating. Nine percent think the government rates shows, and 27% say they don’t know who does the rating.

Parents Say Ratings Accurately Depict TV Content.

Seventy-one percent of parents who use the ratings say they provide “reasonably accurate” information about TV shows, although half (50%) say they have on occasion disagreed with how a particular show was rated. Only 12% of parents who use the ratings say they know who to complain to in such a situation.

Parents would use a v-chip.

Nearly two-thirds of all parents (65%) say that if they had a v-chip in their home, they would use it to block certain programming. But most parents say they are either “not too likely” (24%) or “not at all likely” (45%) to go out and buy a TV with a v-chip (or a set-top box) in the next year or two.

The new ratings, which combine both age-based ratings and content descriptors, were implemented in October 1997 as the result of an agreement among advocacy groups, policymakers and representatives of the television industry. NBC and BET have declined to use the content descriptors. The ratings are designed to work in conjunction with the v-chip device, which will allow parents to block shows with certain ratings from their homes. The v-chip is expected to be available in some new TV sets and in set-top boxes within a year; all new sets will be required to have a v-chip within a year and a half. Following are the rating categories:

TVY: All children. This program is designed to be appropriate for all children.

1398-pix_black.gif

TVY7: Directed to older children. This program is designed for children age 7 and above.

pix_black.gif

TVG: General audience. Most parents would find this program suitable for all ages.

pix_black.gif

TVPG: Parental Guidance Suggested. This program contains material that parents may find unsuitable for younger children.

pix_black.gif

TV14: Parents Strongly Cautioned. This program contains some material that many parents would find unsuitable for children under 14 years of age.

pix_black.gif

TVMA: Mature Audience Only. This program is specifically designed to be viewed by adults and therefore may be unsuitable for children under 17.

pix_black.gif

V: Violent content.

pix_black.gif

S: Sexual content.

pix_black.gif

L: Language.

pix_black.gif

D: Suggestive dialogue.

pix_black.gif

FV: Fantasy violence.

pix_black.gif

Methodology

Parents, Children, and the Television Ratings System reports on the results of two national random sample surveys designed by the Kaiser Family Foundation and Princeton Survey Research Associates (PSRA), and conducted by PSRA by telephone between April 2-26, 1998. 1,358 parents of children ages 2-17 and 446 children ages 10-17 were interviewed. The margin of error for the survey of parents is plus or minus 3%, and for the survey of children is plus or minus 5%.

The Kaiser Family Foundation, based in Menlo Park, California, is an independent national health care philanthropy and not associated with Kaiser Permanente or Kaiser Industries. These surveys were conducted as a part of the Foundation’s Program on the Entertainment Media & Public Health, which was established to examine the impact of entertainment media in society, and to work with the entertainment industry, researchers and policymakers on important public health issues.

Copies of the summary of findings and questionnaires for the surveys reported on in this release are available by calling the Kaiser Family Foundation=s publication request line at 1-800-656-4533 (Ask for #1398).

Return to top

New National Surveys of Parents and Children on TV Ratings System:Press Release

Kaiser Family Foundation National Survey of Latinos on HIV/AIDS – News Release

Published: Apr 29, 1998

Two New Studies On Latinos And AIDS In America:

  • Survey Of Latinos Finds Widespread Concern About HIV/AIDS; Impact Of Disease Felt “Close To Home”
  • Report Documents Impact Of AIDS/HIV On Hispanics And Offers Guidance For Community Health Providers

Embargoed For Release Until:9:30 am, ET, Friday, May 1, 1998

For Further Information Contact: Tina Hoff or Matt James/KFF(650) 854-9400

Xiomara Sosa/COSSMHO(202) 797-4335

Washington, DC — Next week Latino leaders will gather at Harvard University for the first ever Latino “Leading for Life/Unidos Para la Vida” conference to discuss how to address the growing problem of HIV/AIDS among Latinos. As Latino leaders mobilize to address the problem of HIV/AIDS, most Latinos living in the U.S. today say they are extremely concerned about the impact of this deadly disease on their communities, families and themselves, according to a new national survey released today by the Kaiser Family Foundation, along with the National Coalition of Hispanic Health and Human Services Organizations (COSSMHO).

Highlights from the Kaiser Family Foundation National Survey of Latinos on HIV/AIDS:

  • One in two Latinos (50%) rate AIDS as the nation’s most urgent health problem, and nine in ten (91%) say it is a major threat to public health in this country;
  • Half of all Latinos (52%) say AIDS is a more urgent problem today for their local community than it was a few years ago and one in five (20%) say their community is losing ground on AIDS;
  • Two thirds of Latinos (67%) say AIDS is a very serious problem for people they know and a third (35%) say they personally know someone who has HIV or AIDS or who died from AIDS;
  • 46% of Latinos say they are very worried about becoming infected with HIV, a level of worry which far exceeds that among a national sample of all Americans (24%), and 41 percent say their personal worry has grown in recent years.

Responding to the concerns and information needs of Hispanics about HIV/AIDS at the community level, COSSMHO also released today HIV/AIDS: The Impact on Hispanics. This report, which contains the most current data on the AIDS epidemic among Hispanics, including national trends as well as variations by region, supports the need to intensify community-based prevention and education efforts. Produced for community-based organizations, health and human services professionals, and others, it offers information for accessing Hispanics’ response to HIV/AIDS and suggestions for a course of action.

“At a time when public perception moves in the direction of viewing HIV/AIDS as a manageable disease, Hispanic communities continue to be devastated by this epidemic,” said Jane L. Delgado, Ph.D., President and Chief Executive Officer of the National Coalition of Hispanic Health and Human Services Organizations (COSSMHO).

COSSMHO recommends that every comprehensive community-based HIV/AIDS program should have the following:

  • Access to culturally and linguistically appropriate, voluntary and anonymous testing, and appropriate medical care for early diagnosis and treatment of HIV infection;
  • AIDS education curricula (that include information about HIV/AIDS, skill building on condom use, the interpersonal challenges of negotiating safer sex, and avoiding drug use) to be used in junior- and senior-high school settings, and targeted settings for out-of-school youth;
  • Outreach, education, and prevention — including the provision of prevention tools such as sterile injection equipment — to persons who are injecting drugs.

THE FACTS from HIV/AIDS: The Impact on Hispanics:

As of June 1997, a total of 109,252 Hispanic AIDS cases had been reported in the U.S. While Hispanics make up 12 percent of the U.S. population (including Puerto Rico), they account for 18 percent of all AIDS cases in this country. This represents a continued upward trend: in 1995, Hispanics accounted for 15 percent of all AIDS cases. While AIDS mortality declined by 32 percent in 1996 for non-Hispanic whites, Hispanics experienced a 20 percent decline and non-Hispanic blacks a 13 percent decline.

There is significant variation in the regional distribution of Hispanic AIDS cases by exposure category. In the Eastern part of the U.S. and Puerto Rico, injection drug use (IDU) constitutes the most significant exposure category for Hispanic AIDS cases (MA, NJ, NY). For the other states studied in this report (AZ, CA, CO, FL, IL, NM, TX), men who have sex with men represent the most significant exposure category.

The Role of Information in Fighting HIV/AIDS

According to the Kaiser Family Foundation survey, almost all Latinos know that HIV is sexually transmitted (98%) and that a pregnant woman with HIV can pass it to her baby (92%). Slightly fewer, though still the majority, know there is no cure for AIDS (77%) and that no vaccine against HIV is available (68%).

“Even those who are most knowledgeable about AIDS say there is more information they want, especially about the most practical aspects of HIV prevention: how to talk with children and partners, and where to go for testing and treatment,” said Sophia Chang, MD, Director of HIV Programs, Kaiser Family Foundation.

While Latinos know the basic facts about HIV/AIDS, most say there are areas they want to know more about, such as how to talk with children (70%) and partners (51%) about this disease and where to go if exposed to HIV for testing (58%) and treatment (63%). Many (41%) also say that to help guard against the spread of HIV they want more information about how to properly use condoms. Importantly, respondents interviewed in Spanish (50% of the sample) cited an even greater desire for information in all areas, highlighting the importance of making education and prevention materials available in both English and Spanish.

The media, especially television and radio, is a leading source of information about HIV/AIDS for Latinos. Seven in ten Latinos (70%) say they heard something about HIV/AIDS in the past month on a television news program, and two in five (44%) got information from an entertainment show on television. Radio talk or call-in shows (42%) and other radio programming (34%) also figure as information sources. Beyond the media, health care providers (32%), family and friends (28%), and the church (20%) are the next most commonly named resources on HIV/AIDS. There is also some variation in information resources used by Latinos depending on the language of their interview: Latinos who were surveyed in Spanish were most likely to have gotten information about HIV/AIDS from broadcast outlets, including television news (73%) and entertainment (49%) programming and radio call-in or talk shows (48%); those who were interviewed in English also most frequently named television news programs (67%), but were more likely to turn to print media such as magazines (56%) and newspapers (50%).

Taking the Lead: Whose Responsibility?

Latinos see a variety of players in the fight against AIDS, giving slightly higher marks to community level efforts than to government. Latinos see community groups, such as local health care providers, churches, and schools, as among the most concerned and most active in reducing the impact of the epidemic. Fewer Latinos say government at any level cares or does as much in the fight against AIDS. Among all groups — community and government — Latinos leave room for more action.

In terms of what is needed to fight against the disease, Latinos strongly support more government efforts. Two in five (44%) say the government spends too little money on HIV/AIDS and the majority supports increased spending across a range of areas including education and other prevention activities (94%), expanding access to new drug therapies (94%), and research to find more effective treatments (95%) as well as a vaccine (94%).

A majority (56%) of Latinos also favor needle exchange – programs that offer clean needles to IV drug users in exchange for used ones. Opinions on this issue, however, appear to be influenced by how it is presented. When given an argument made by opponents of needle exchange – that it gives tacit approval of illegal drug use – support is lower among Latinos: 41% favor, 56% oppose.


Survey Methodology

The Kaiser Family Foundation National Survey of Latinos on HIV/AIDS is a random-sample national survey of 802 Latino adults, 18 years and older. The survey was designed by staff at the Foundation and conducted by telephone in both English and Spanish by Princeton Survey Research Associates (PSRA) between September 19 and October 26, 1997. The margin of sampling error is plus or minus 4 percent. The margin of sampling error may be higher for some of the sub-sets in this analysis.

The Kaiser Family Foundation, based in Menlo Park, California, is an independent national health care philanthropy and is not associated with Kaiser Permanente or Kaiser Industries.

The National Coalition of Hispanic Health and Human Services Organizations (COSSMHO) for 25 years has been connecting communities and creating change to improve the health and well-being of Hispanics in the United States. Headquartered in Washington, DC, COSSMHO is the sole national organization focusing on the health and human services needs of the diverse Hispanic communities. COSSMHO’s membership consists of thousands of front-line health and human services providers and organizations serving Hispanic communities in the United States and Puerto Rico.

A more detailed report on the survey findings, including analysis by age, gender, region of the country, religion, income and education, is available by calling the Kaiser Family Foundation’s publication request line at 1-800-656-4533 (Ask for 1392 in English or 1393 in Spanish).

Measuring the Effects of Sexual Content in the Media:  A Report to the Kaiser Family Foundation – Report

Published: Apr 29, 1998

Measuring the Effects of Sexual Content in the Media: A Report to the Kaiser Family Foundation

1389-pdffile.gifThis Report is available in Adobe Acrobat Format

Author: Drs. Aletha C. Huston, Ellen Wartella, and Edward Donnerstein

Executive Summary

The Kaiser Family Foundation has an ongoing interest in sexual health among young people and the potential contributions of mass media to sexual behavior. This report was prepared at the request of the Foundation to examine the methodological options for investigating the effects of sexual content in the media on children and adolescents. In preparing the report, we convened a Forum of twenty scholars with expertise in sexuality, sexual development, media analysis, and media effects to discuss these issues.

The purposes of this report are to review what we know about the relations of entertainment media to sexual development during childhood and adolescence, to consider methodological issues and challenges in studying this topic, and to propose some fruitful directions for future research.

There are many opinions about the effects of sexual content in the mass media, and they are often couched in political or religious overtones. This report is not intended to debate these opinions, rather, it is a review and discussion of social scientific methods which provide publicly shared, objective, empirical, and replicable information that can be used to build a cumulative body of knowledge of this area.

Although the effects of sexual content have received relatively little attention from researchers, there have been content analytic studies of the portrayals of sexuality in television and movies and there is evidence that sexual messages in entertainment media have been increasing.

Studies of sexual messages in movies and on television (prime-time, soaps, and music videos have been studied most heavily) have found that over the past twenty years, there has been an overall increase in the number of portrayals and the amount of talk about sex in these media and an increase in the explicitness of these portrayals. Furthermore, the television research shows a fairly consistent sexual message across TV genres: most portrayals of sex depict or imply heterosexual intercourse between unmarried adults, with little reference to STDs/AIDS, pregnancy, or use of contraception.

There are sound theoretical reasons to believe that television and other media can play an important role in educating children and adolescents about sexuality. Media portrayals surround children and adolescents, and young people are intensely interested in sexuality, romance, and relationships.

Yet, there are very, very few studies of the effects of sexual messages in the media on child and adolescent viewers. The few experimental studies show that television has the potential to change viewers’ attitudes and knowledge. Correlational designs provide weak evidence that television viewing is linked with sexual behavior and beliefs, but the measures of viewing are crude at best. There also is some evidence that such personal factors as interest in sexual content, level of understanding, perceived reality, and parental mediation modify the influence of sexual messages. Much more empirical work is needed to substantiate the claim that naturally occurring sexual content in the media actually does cause changes in attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors. Such changes need to be examined as a function of what individuals are watching, the messages they are receiving, how they are interpreting them, and other factors that influence a young person’s sexual personae.

Two approaches to sexual development are reviewed in this report. Healthy sex, or the role of sex in individual mental health and in healthy relationships, focuses on enabling people of all ages to develop the attitudes, values, and behaviors that promote healthy sexual functioning. In this approach, sex is considered good and essential to human functioning. The second orientation, sexual health, has a narrower focus based in public health concerns about the physical disease, mental health, and social problems that can arise from sexual behavior. The majority of the literature in this area is concerned with STDs, including HIV, and unwanted, early, or out-of-wedlock pregnancy, but sexual violence and coercion, including rape, and mental health problems (e.g., depression, low self-esteem, distorted body image) also are considered. The sexual health literature tends to focus on prevention through encouraging young people to abstain from or postpone sexual intercourse, especially with multiple partners, and by encouraging them to use “safer sex” practices when they do have intercourse.

Research designed to understand the influence of mass media on sexual health must be informed by an understanding of the developmental changes in sexuality during childhood and adolescence, as well as socioeconomic, cultural, family, and peer influences. At the very least many of these influences must be controlled in studying media effects. Perhaps more important, it is likely that the processes involved and outcomes of interest will differ for different groups of young people. If we are to completely understand the effects of sexual content in the media we need to consider a range of outcomes — cognitive, emotional, attitudinal, behavioral — either separately or in combination with one other. In addition, we need to be cognizant of vast individual differences in how viewers respond to sexual depictions.

There are several inherent ethical and practical problems in doing research on children’s and adolescents’ sexual knowledge, attitudes, and behavior. The broad outline of these issues can be subsumed under several general principles regarding the protection of human subjects, which have been articulated by the federal research directors. Specific concerns regarding how various institutional research boards (IRBs) interpret these general guidelines, and gaining parental consent when children and adolescents are the subjects in a study also pose barriers to research.

The report suggests that researchers can design and conduct important research within these national and local guidelines. We recommend research based on the following premises:

  1. Research in this area should be conducted by interdisciplinary teams of investigators, with expertise in the area of sexual development and others with expertise in media research.
  2. There is need for an accumulated body of systematic studies using a variety of methods with a variety of populations. Given the paucity of available studies and the need to develop a systematic research base, no one grand study will provide definitive answers.
  3. Research on the effects of sexual media content should in general begin with small-scale studies and move to larger field and longitudinal studies. Small-scale studies (laboratory, survey, observational) can permit refinement of questions, measures and methods in a relatively low-cost and efficient way.
  4. Research must take into account developmental, gender and ethnic differences. The functions and effects of sexual media content in sexual development may vary substantially for boys and girls, for different ethnic groups, and across different age groups.
  5. There is a need for the development of valid and reliable measures of the use of media sexual content and of outcome measures of sexual knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors. One cannot generalize the validity or reliability of measures used with adult populations to children and adolescents particularly in this research domain.

In addition to the premises laid out above, the report provides some more specific recommendations about what kinds of studies should be conducted. We encourage researchers to think creatively about additional research design options.

There is little existing research literature that addresses the issue of children’s media use patterns. Any attempt to understand the influence of media on young people should begin with an assessment of both the amount and patterns of media use among children. Given the recent explosion in new media choices such as the Internet, computer games, and niche cable channels, it is imperative that we have an understanding of what media kids are using, and how and why they are using them.

Though many studies have looked at the amount and nature of sexual depictions on television, future content analyses should be more theoretically guided and contextually situated. Future research should include in its framework theories about sexuality, sexual development, and media effects. In addition, most content analyses have been limited to certain genres of television programming. Future content analyses should include cable programming, advertising, news, talk shows and new media.

In studying the effects of sexual media content on viewers, it is important to consider the various types of outcomes, including cognitive, emotional, attitudinal, and behavioral. In the early stages of conducting research on this topic, small experimental studies are likely to be more useful than correlational studies. Some of the proposed experimental techniques include manipulating outcomes of sexual media messages to measure immediate effects on children’s knowledge, schemas, attitudes and even behaviors.

A second phase of research could employ the field experiment technique, best used in cooperation with the media industry. The body of the report identifies two successful examples of field experiments, and recommendations for future field experiments on sexual content.

Once preliminary research is conducted on the effects of sexual content, an accelerated longitudinal design with overlapping cohorts would be the next recommended approach. This design would maximize the information obtainable in a five-year period, and would allow for follow-up in later years, were funding available.

Our final recommendation concerns the process for bootstrapping research in this entire area. As we have previously noted there is little systematic knowledge about the effects of sexual content. We certainly encourage research across many disciplines and funding agencies (both federal and private), but a central guiding framework is needed. We believe that an initiative akin to the Surgeon General’s 1970 study of Television and Social Behavior would be useful. A collaborative effort by the Kaiser Family Foundation, working with other foundations, could produce a coordinated research base collected in a major report that would provide a solid foundation for understanding the effects of sexual media content and could serve as a basis for future funding and research.

Return to top

Measuring the Effects of Sexual Content in the MediaReport

Federal HIV/AIDS Spending: A Budget Chartbook

Published: Apr 29, 1998

This chartbook provides a general guide to the more than $8 billion in federal funding allotted in 1998 for HIV/AIDS research, prevention, care and assistance and international programs. It serves to assist in identification of the types of programs supported, as well as recent spending trends.

You can find the latest version of the report here.

Note: This publication is no longer in circulation. However, a copy may still exist in the Foundation’s internal library that could reproduced. Please email order@kff.org if you would like to pursue this option.

Parents, Children and the Television Ratings System: Two Kaiser Family Foundation Surveys

Published: Apr 29, 1998

The television ratings system was designed to help address concerns about television content by giving parents assistance in monitoring what their children watch. This survey asks parents and children about their knowledge, opinions and use of the TV ratings system. 446 children ages 10-17 were also interviewed. The survey was conducted for the Foundation by Princeton Survey Research Associates.

Measuring the Effects of Sexual Content in the Media: A Report to the Kaiser Family Foundation

Published: Apr 29, 1998

Measuring the Effects of Sexual Content in the Media: A Report to the Kaiser Family Foundation

This report provides a history of the research on sexual content in the media, an overview of the methods available for studying the effects of media, a discussion of some of the difficulties in doing research on this topic, and specific recommendations for future research on the effects on young viewers of sexual content in the media. This Report is available in Adobe Acrobat Format

Poll Finding

Kaiser Family Foundation National Survey of Latinos on HIV/AIDS

Published: Apr 29, 1998

A random-sample national survey of 802 Latino adults, 18 years and older. The survey, designed by staff at the Foundation and conducted by telephone in both English and Spanish by Princeton Survey Research Associates (PSRA), examines Latino’s knowledge, values and beliefs with respect to HIV and AIDS. The survey data is also broken down into subgroups within the Latino community including women, young adults, parents, opinion leaders, and those with less education and lower incomes. The findings were presented at the first ever Latino “Leading for Life/Unidos Para la Vida” conference to discuss how to address the growing problem of HIV/AIDS among Latinos. This report is also available in Spanish as #1393 .

News Release

HTML Version of Report